Jacksonville Jaguars
The Jaguars started in 1995 like a rockstar, had Mark Brunell throwing passes, Jimmy Smith catching them, and a defense that bit your ass. They made the playoffs four years straight, then lost to the Titans twice and got kicked out of the Super Bowl like a beggar.
'Mark Brunell was the reason I stayed up past my bedtime.'
'Jimmy Smith caught more balls than my mom catches gossip.'
'The Titans beat them like they were on a team called the Jaguars, not the Jaguars.'